On June 7th a statue of Edward Colston
(1636-1721) a merchant and slave trader was toppled from its plinth by Black Lives Matter protesters and dumped
in Bristol Harbour.
On July 15th a statue depicting one of the
protesters was, without permission, put in its place. It was subsequently
removed by the authorities.
To bring attention to a cause by way of Civil Disobedience
is not easy, as those of us who have taken this route well know. Very often it
is left to an individual to draw attention to an injustice. It cannot be done
in disguise or under the protection of a pseudonym. Most prefer the safer option of patiently
waiting for change. But if Rosa Parks had patiently waited, public transport in
Montgomery might still be segregated.
The Bristol episode has not only served to bring
home the message of the protesters, but also to illustrate that art in general,
and public sculpture in particular, has a role to play in social
commentary. A work of art may be
perceived as controversial, but therein lies its significance.
The techniques and materials used by Marc Quinn
are far removed from those handed down by sculptors through the centuries.
However, to make the statement in record time I accept that it was the only way
possible. I give credit the artist and Jen Reid, his model, for seizing the
opportunity. As Marc Quinn stated, the computer generated black resin statue
was meant to be a temporary installation. Its purpose was to continue the
conversation about racism.
In terms of that conversation, it comes as a
surprise that Thomas Price, a black British sculptor, who has recently been
commissioned to create a sculpture dedicated the Windrush Generation, has
accused Marc Quinn of creating a “votive statue to appropriation”. He goes on to state: “I
think it would be far more useful if white artists confronted whiteness as
opposed to using the lack of black representation in art to find relevance for
themselves.”
From that perspective it might be argued that 130
years ago Paul Gauguin should have stayed in France and not sailed to Tahiti
and that 55 years ago I should have stayed in my native West Riding of
Yorkshire and not sailed to the Caribbean.